Your Dhimmi idea is a fascinating one.
Do you think the SJ program is capable of developing a concept such as this and implementing it somewhat universally? I don’t think it has the ability in its current form.
Some of the peer review responses to the recent Pluckrose Triad’s spoof work seem to indicate that even the “allies” are under attack at this phase of SJ, and have at a minimum been hedged out of the crowdsourcing effort. One of their two Feminist Mein Kampf articles was rejected not because it was based on Hitler, but rather because the “author” was a white lesbian, and the editor claimed the “author” didn’t do a good enough job attoning for their whiteness.
If SJ is going to stick around much longer, they’re going to have to plug that hole at a minimum.